|

|
Saker Contact Information
Lady Ines Alfón
Sheryl Niemann
8339 Antioch Road
Overland Park, KS 66212
913-544-2436 (no calls after 9 PM please) |
| |
For results of submissions
sent to the SCA Laurel-of-Arms office before 2005,
use the links above to check out the results of previous years.
This page last updated on:
02/23/2008 13:22:46 -0700
| For the Latest ILoI and
ELoI please visit those pages. |
| |
|
Results from
Laurel are IN! |
|
ELoI Letter
Designation: JM-E24
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
November 24,
2004.
Date the Saker Office received the
results of the Laurel Decision:
June 6, 2005 |
ELoI Letter Designation:
JM-E25
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
February 14,
2005.
Date the Saker Office received the
results of the Laurel Decision:
September 9, 2005 |
|
ELoI Letter Designation:
JM-E26
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
April
28, 2005
Date the Saker Office received the
results of the Laurel Decision:
November 2005 |
ELoI Letter
Designation: 20050610-LOI-CAL-MDB
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
June 10, 2005
Date the Saker Office received the
results of the Laurel Decision:
January 9, 2006 |
ELoI
Letter
Designation:
20050820-LOI-CAL-MDB
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
August 20, 2005
Date the Saker Herald Office received the results of the Laurel decisions:
March 4, 2006 |
|
|
Awaiting Laurel
Decision |
|
|
|
ELoI Letter
Designation: 20051231-LOI-CAL-MDB
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
December 31, 2005
Date the Saker Office received the
results of the Laurel Decision: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
At Kingdom Saker Herald's Office
Returned at Kingdom |
|
|
The following items have been decided by
Laurel.
ELoI Letter
Designation: JM-E24
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
November 24,
2004.
Date the Laurel-of-Arms Office decides on these submissions:
Scheduled for the April 2005 meeting
Date the Saker Herald Office received the results of the Laurel
decisions:
June 6, 2005 |
| |
Submitter's Name & Group |
Item(s) |
Decision by Laurel |
| 1. |
Alpin Dunmore
<Coeur d’Ennui> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 2. |
Annika
Murchadha
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as Anneke
inghean Mhurchadha
Submitted
as Annika Murchadha, this name mixes Gaelic and
Finnish in the same name, but no documentation was submitted and none
found showing substantial contact between Finnish and Gaelic speaking
cultures in period. Barring such documentation, such combinations are
not registerable. In addition, the name proposes Murchadha as a
patronymic byname. However, this form makes it an unmarked patronymic,
and there is no evidence for the use of unmarked patronymics in Gaelic
names. We have changed the name to Anneke inghean Mhurchadha
in order to register it. Sveriges medeltida personnamn dates
Anneke to 1465. The patronymic particle inghean is the Early
Modern Gaelic particle meaning "daughter" which matches the Early Modern
Irish form of the patronymic; we have added this particle to the byname,
and lenited the patronymic as is required by Gaelic grammar.
Device Passed: Per pale purpure
and vert, a lizard tergiant embowed-counterembowed argent. |
| 3. |
Antonia
Stefani
<Heraldshill> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 4. |
Cassandra
Isabella Borghi
<Oakheart> |
BADGE |
Badge Returned:
Multiple Conflicts
This badge must be returned for multiple
conflicts. Since the grapes are effectively a maintained charge, there
are conflicts with Graffico de Drell, Vert, entwined about a chalice
Or, a serpent head to sinister sable, and Melisande de Belvoir,
Argent, a chalice Or, upon the dexter lip, a honeybee proper. In
both cases, there is a CD for fieldlessness, but nothing for changes to
a maintained charge. The badge also conflicts with Ladies of the Bay,
Per saltire azure and gules, a goblet Or, Mary of Livermore, Per
chevron argent and gules, in base a goblet Or, and Carl of
Sutherland, Quarterly azure and erminois in dexter chief a goblet Or.
In each case, there is only the CD for fielded versus fielded armory
(since, in the latter two cases, there is no difference for location on
the field versus a fieldless badge). |
| 5. |
Catrijn
vanden Westhende
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed:
Nice Name!
Device Returned:
Conflicts
Conflict with Georgia the Pragmatic of
Clyffmarsh, (Fieldless) A lotus in profile azure, slipped vert,
with only one CD for fielded versus fielded armory. |
| 6. |
Caitriona ó
Floinn of Corke
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Caitríona inghean ui Fhloinn of Corke
Submitted as
Caitríona ó Floinn of Corke, the name combines a
feminine given name with a masculine patronymic. In Gaelic, the gender
of the patronymic particle must agree with the gender of the given
name. In addition, the patronymic must be lenited. We have changed the
name to Caitríona inghean uí Fhloinn of Corke to
correct the grammar.
No
documentation was included for the element Corke. Had the
College not provided documentation for this element, it would have been
dropped. However, Orle notes "A Tudor Atlas by John Speed from 1611
page 283 under Munster lists the town as Corke."
Device Passed: Argent, a cat
couchant sable and a bordure invected purpure semy of shamrocks argent. |
| 7. |
Emma Miner
<La Grande Tente> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per bend vert
and azure, a quill of yarn and a loaf of bread Or. |
| 8. |
Esa Southwick
<Bellewode> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Azure, on a fess
between three Celtic crosses argent a dragon passant azure. |
| 9. |
Jean Pierre
d’Armand
<Three Rivers> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 10. |
John Paul
Bowyer
<La Grande Tente> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 11. |
Loch
Meadhonach, Shire of
<Loch
Meadhonach> |
DEVICE
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Azure, five
roundels argent in annulo within a laurel wreath, a chief embattled Or. |
| 12. |
Martinus Draco Byzantinos
<Cúm
an Iolair> |
BADGE |
Badge Passed: Azure, a chi-rho
and a bordure Or. |
| 13. |
Melisent
McAffee
<Oakheart> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
There is a more than
300 year gap between the 1201 date for the given name and the 1595 date
of the byname. This is one step from period practice.
Device Returned:
Blurred distinction between per chevron
division and a point pointed.
This device must be returned for blurring
the distinction between a per chevron division and a point pointed.
Please advise the submitter to draw it as clearly one or the other if
she chooses to resubmit this design in the future. |
| 14. |
Merick
Bromfield
<Deodar> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 15. |
Mevanwy verch
Tuder Courtecadeno
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
The Saint
Gabriel report used to document this name says this about the use of
Welsh locative bynames in Anglo-Latin documents: "In Anglo-Latin
documents, the place name tended to be used without the preposition <de>
when the locative was the only byname, but with <de> when there was
another byname present." This seems to indicate that locative bynames
were occassionally, but rarely, found without the de when there
was another byname present. The more usual form of this name would be
Mevanwy verch Tuder de Courtecadeno.
Device Passed: Or, a greyhound
statant gules and a bordure embattled vert. |
| 16. |
Onóra Ébliu
nic Leod
<Oakheart> |
NAME, DEVICE &
BADGE |
Name Passed
Submitted
as Onóra Ébliu nic Leod, the submitter
requested a name authentic to 12th C Scotland. As submitted the name has
several problems. First, it has two given names, which is unattested in
period Gaelic names. Second, it uses the patronymic marker nic,
which is not found until after our period. Both of these things must be
fixed for the name to be registerable. Finally, the name combines
Gaelic and Anglo-Norman spellings; if the submitter is interested in an
authentic name, then only one language should be used throughout. In the
12th C, the proper form for the patronymic would be inghean Leoid.
Therefore, we have changed this name to Onóra inghean Leoid
to make it registerable and to partially comply with the submitter's
request for authenticity.
Device Passed: Per bend
sinister sable and argent, a decrescent argent and a compass star
elongated to base purpure.
Badge Returned:
Conflicts
This badge conflicts with the protected
symbol of the Red Crescent, Argent, a decrescent gules, with only
one CD for changing the tincture of the primary charge. |
| 17. |
Rhodri ap Ieuan ap Hywel
<Vatavia> |
DEVICE –
CHANGE |
Device Changed: Azure, a
dragon passant and a bordure engrailed Or.
This device does not conflict with Roger
of Belden Abbey, Azure, a two-headed dragon passant respectant Or,
turbanned argent, gorged of a collar gules, pendant therefrom a bell
argent, in base a bumblebee displayed erect proper. There is a CD
for changing the secondary bumblebee to a bordure engrailed and another
for changing half its tincture. Bees proper have argent wings, and we
have often given a CD for changing the tincture of the wings on various
charges when the visual weight of the wings is equivalent to half the
charge, as it is in this case. To cite one example from precedent,
registering (Fieldless) A dragonfly vert winged Or, Laurel wrote,
"After examining the emblazon, it is clear that Ann's dragonfly is half
vert and half Or, thereby giving it one CD for fieldlessness and one CD
for change to half the tincture in each case" [Ann Travers of Amberlye,
05/00, A-Caid].
He wishes
to retain his former device, Azure, two swords in saltire, overall a
dragon passant contourny argent, as a badge.
|
| 18. |
Victoria atte
Rose
<Cúm an Iolair> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name:
Holding name of Victoria of Cúm an
Iolair. Name conflics with
Victoria Rose, registered January 2004.
Conflict with
Victoria Rose, registered January 2004. In general, the addition or
deletion of a preposition does not contribute to difference.
Her armory has been
registered under the holding name Victoria of Cúm an Iolair.
Device Passed: Per bend
sinister Or and Purpure, a spiderweb purpure and a keythong's head
erased Or.
While
spiderwebs are described in Guillim's Display of Heraldry, 1632,
the only known examples show the spiderweb alone and covering the entire
field. Using the spiderweb on only half the field is thus a step from
period practice. |
| 19. |
Wilhelm Meis
<Crystal Mynes> |
DEVICE
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Argent, a
chevron between two estoiles azure and an eagle sable. |
The following items have been decided by
Laurel.
ELoI Letter
Designation: JM-E25
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
February 14,
2005.
Date the Laurel-of-Arms Office decides on these submissions:
June 2005
Date the Saker Herald Office received the results of the Laurel decisions:
September 9, 2005 |
| |
Submitter's Name & Group |
Item(s) |
Decision by Laurel |
| 1.
|
Aengus
Stiubhard Mac Dhughaill
<Aston Tor> |
DEVICE – CHANGE
|
Device Passed: Barry wavy argent
and azure, a ship gules and a chief wavy sable mulletty Or. |
| 2. |
Áine
Finnólfsdottir
<Lost Moor> |
NAME |
Name Passed
|
| 3.
|
Amba
allrasystir
<Forgotten Sea> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Azure, an alphyn
passant and on a chief Or three step-cut gemstones azure. |
| 4.
|
Amira bint
Mikhail of Safita
<Contact Group> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 5.
|
Andor
Ólgarðr
<Cúm an
Iolair> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Andor i Ólgarði
Device Passed: Argent semy of maple
leaves gules, an eagle azure and a bordure sable. |
| 6.
|
Catalina
Artemisia Anguissola
<Aston Tor> |
DEVICE CHANGE
|
Device Passed: Azrue, a winged fish
volant bendwise and in base a bar wavy Or. |
| 7. |
Catalina
Artemisia Anguissola
<Aston Tor> |
ALTERNATE NAME
of Katelina Björnsdotter |
Alternate Name Passed as
Katelina Biornsdottir |
| 8.
|
Catalina
Artemisia Anguissola
<Aston Tor> |
BADGE |
Badge Passed: Per pale purpure and Or all semy of bears sejant
erect counterchanged. |
| 9.
|
Conall
Fearghas na Carraigh
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Conall mac Fearghasa Charraigh
Device Passed: Per chevron gules
and azure, a wolf couchant contourny and two triquetras bases to center
one and two argent. |
| 10. |
Constantia
Innocenti
<Three Rivers> |
DEVICE |
Device Passed: Or, on a bend
sinister dancetty purpure between two rats rampant gules trhee hands
inverted Or. |
| 11.
|
Dammo von
Uttenweiller
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Dammo Utwiler
Device Returned:
Conflicts |
| 12.
|
Eoin
Ravenscroft
<Contact Group> |
DEVICE
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Or, a raven
contourny perched atop and maintaining a crossbow fesswise reversed, in
dexter chief a tower sable, a bordure wavy azure. |
| 13.
|
Elena de
Rennes
< > |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per pale argent and
azure, a demi-sun counterchanged. |
| 14.
|
Finán mac
Domnaill
<Contact Group> |
DEVICE
|
Device Passed: Per pale vert
and azure, a harp argent between in pale two arrows fesswise reversed
Or, a bordure argent. |
| 15.
|
Gabrielle
D'evereaux
< > |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Gabrielle d'Evereaux
Device not addressed |
| 16. |
Gracye Malley
<Vatavia> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 17.
|
Giric Taillur
<Aston Tor> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Argent semy of
Lochaber axes sable, on a bend sinister purpure a crossbow argent. |
| 18. |
Lucia Ottavia
da Siena
<Three Rivers> |
DEVICE CHANGE
|
Device Returned:
Conflicts |
| 19.
|
Olaus of
Skjærvøy
<Axed Root> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Olaus af Scherffø
Device Passed: Or, a standing balance
purpure an on a chief dovetailed vert three open books Or. |
| 20.
|
Phaedra of
Vatavia
<Vatavia> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Returned:
Conflicts |
| 21.
|
Quiteria la
Roja
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Quarterly argent and
gules, two cats sejant contourny gules. |
| 22.
|
Ros Fionn
inghean Domhnall
<Three Rivers> |
NAME
Device returned at
Kingdom |
Name Passed as
Rós Fhionn inghean Domhnaill |
| 23.
|
Steffen
Albert Rheinbauer
< > |
DEVICE
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Azure, a sinister
gauntlet clenched aversant bendwise sustaining a rose slipped and leaved
bendwise sinsister argent, in chief a mural coronet, all within an orle
of chain Or. |
| 24.
|
Sven
Gostafson von Bremen
<Vatavia> |
CHANGE OF
HOLDING NAME from Sven of Vatavia |
Name Passed as
Sven Gøstafson von Bremen |
| 25.
|
Taliesin of
Lyonesse
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Returned:
Holding name of Taliesin of Three Rivers
Device Passed: Quarterly argent and
sable, a cross flory and a bordure counterchanged.
Comment of "Nice armory" |
| 26.
|
Willewyn
Glaswryghte
<Three Rivers> |
NAME CHANGE from
Willewyn of Three Rivers |
Name Passed |
The following items have been decided by
Laurel.
ELoI Letter
Designation: JM-E26
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
April
28, 2005
Date the Laurel-of-Arms Office decides on these submissions:
August
2005
Date the Saker Herald Office received the results of the Laurel decisions:
November 2005 |
| |
Submitter's Name & Group |
Item(s) |
Decision by Laurel |
| 1. |
Alessandra de Piro
<Bellewode> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Returned:
This is returned for a redraw as the waves are
drawn as wavy bretessed. This non-period style has long been
grounds for return. On resubmission, the submitter is advised that the
ford should be drawn with four or more traits instead of three. |
| 2. |
Berenguera Fineya
<Deodar> |
NAME CHANGE from Finé
Macrennie & DEVICE |
Name Change Passed
(old name, Finé Macrennie, is released)
Device Passed:
Or estencelly vert, an opinicus salient
gules and a dexter tierce vert. |
| 3. |
Dash Unegan
<Aston Tor> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Dash Unegen
Device Passed: Or, a broken
snaffle-bit chevronwise inverted sable within five arrows in annulo
gules. |
| 4. |
Edmund Barbarossa
<Bellewode> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Sable, in pale three
cartouches fesswise argent each charged with a spider passant contourny
gules. |
| 5. |
Eiríkr Elgr Eiriksson
<Deodar> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 6. |
Elena McKenzie
<Coeur d'Ennui> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed:
Purpure,
two cutlasses in saltire edges to chief and a base rayonny Or.
Blazoned as scimitars, these swords lack the
curvature and general shape of a heraldic scimitar (cf. Pictorial
Dictiionary, q.v. Sword). We have reblazoned these as cutlasses,
which sword type dates at least to 1594 according to the OED. |
| 7. |
Elinor Salter
<Deodar> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Argent, a wyvern
sejant between three estoiles gules. |
| 8. |
Flinthyll, Shire of
< - > |
DEVICE RESUBMISSION
(re-draw) |
Device Passed: Per pale purpure and
sable, a laurel wreath Or between three elfbolts argent.
This was blazoned on the LoI as Per pale purpure and
sable, in pall a laurel wreath Or between three elfbolts argent. The
laurel wreath is large enough - though it could be drawn larger - to be
a primary charge between three secondaries. It has been blazoned as
such. |
| 9. |
Fujiwara no Kitsume
<Deodar> |
ALTERNATE NAME of Kytte de
Wodeford,
DEVICE & BADGE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Argent, in fess
three cedar trees eradicated purpure and a base wavy barry wavy purpure
and argent.
Badge Returned:
This is being returned for lack of identifiability; RfS
VII.7.a requires that "Elements must be recognizable solely from their
appearance". In this emblazon, the trees have lost their identity as
trees due to the manner of conjoining them. |
| 10. |
Gabrielle von
Friedrichsthal
<Three Rivers> |
DEVICE RESUBMISSION
|
Device Passed: Per chevron inverted
purpure and sable, a chevron inverted between a garb Or and two bees Or
marked sable. |
| 11. |
Galen Bogle MacHugh
<Crystal Mynes> |
NAME |
Name Passed as
Galen Bogile MacHugh
Submitted as Galen Bogle MacHugh, the spelling for the
byname Bogle is a header spelling. However, all of the spellings dated
to period include a vowel or a y between the g and the l. We have
changed this byname to Bogile, a form dated to the mid 16th C in Black. |
| 12. |
Giudo di Niccolo
Brunelleschi
<Deodar> |
NAME, DEVICE & BADGE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per pale embattled
barry purpure and Or and gules, two lozenges in pale Or.
Badge Returned:
Unfortunately this nice badge conflicts with Damon
Kirby's device, Argent vetu gules, four lozenges in cross gules. The CD
for fieldlessness is the only CD as, by precedent (q.v. Mari Alexander,
10/2004, R-West), there is not a CD for conjoining the lozenges. |
| 13. |
Giuliana Dragonetti
<Cúm an
Iolair> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Sable, on a fess
bretessed between three chamfrons Or, a dragon passant purpure. |
| 14. |
Gotfridus von Schwaben
<Dun Ard> |
BADGE RESUBMISSION (re-draw) |
Badge
Passed: (Fieldless) A double-headed eagle displayed per pale gules
and Or ermined vert. |
| 15. |
Gwenhwyfar Grek
<Deodar> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 16. |
Herman Mandel
<Cúm an
Iolair> |
BADGE |
Badge
Passed: Bendy azure and argent, a sinister wing terminating in a hand
sable sustaining an axe bendwise gules. |
| 17. |
Iago Goodwin
<Mag Mor> |
NAME |
Name Passed |
| 18. |
Kaios Alexandros Barbarou
<Forgotten Sea> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Kaios Alexandrou
Submitted as Kaios Alexandros Barbarou, there is a
more than 1000 year gap between the date for the first given name, Kaios,
and the descriptive byname, Barabrou. The name Kaios was documented in
"Greek Lexicon of Personal Names," which lists names from the earliest
records through the 6th C. However, the only date we were able to find
for this name was prior to 331 BC. The article "Duris of Samos: Early
Ties with Sicily," by Robert B. Kebric American Journal of Archaeology ©
1975 notes that the family of Duris of Samos sought refuge in 321 B.C.
and says of Duris "...his father's name Kaios, extremely rare if not
unique, appeas to have had an origin in the West: Pape-Benseler make it
the equivalent of the Latin Caius, a name not known widely in the fourth
century since Roman influence was generally confined to Italy." While it
is possible that this name came more into use later, it seems unlikely
since the "Greek Lexicon of Personal Names" only finds one example of
it. In addition, the volume from which this name is taken includes names
from the island of Samos, making it likely that the name found is the
same father of Duris in Kebric's article. The byname Barbarou is found
in "Byzantine Seals: 1025-1261", hence there must be more than 1000
years between the dates for Kaios and Barbarou. We have changed the name
to Kaios Alexandrou in order to register it; Alexandrou is the standard
genitive form of Alexandros. If the submitter is interested in a later
Greek name, Alexandros Barbarou would be an appropriate form of this
name.
Device Passed: Per saltire gules
and sable, an alphyn rampant and in chief three annulets interlaced in
fess argent.
The alphyn's front legs are separated; the back legs
are separated but both are planted. This is an acceptable variant of
rampant. In fact, Siebmacher's 1605 Wappenbuch shows pretty much all its
rampant animals with both feet on the same level or with the "away" foot
only very slightly raised. |
| 19. |
Madeleine Rose de Cardeville
<Three Rivers> |
BADGE RESUBMISSION
|
Badge
Passed: Argent semy of hearts gules, on a fess cotised sable a
capital letter M argent. |
| 20. |
Mairi Rose
<Deodar> |
NAME, DEVICE & BADGE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Argent vêtu ployé
vert, on a golpe a triquetra argent.
Badge Passed: Argent, on a golpe
between flaunches vert, a triquetra argent.
This name
mixes Gaelic and Scots; this is one step from period practice. The
submitter requested authenticity for 13th-14th C. However, names that
mix two orthographies are almost never authentic; for an authentic name,
the name should be render fully in a single orthography. If the
submitter is interested in an authentic Scots name for her time period,
we suggest Marie Rose; Marie is dated to 1296 in Black The Surnames of
Scotland s.n. Glengavel. As we do not have a Gaelic form of the locative
Rose, we cannot suggest a fully Gaelic form for this name.
This does not conflict with Amber Lang, Vert, on a lozenge argent, a cat
sejant guardant sable. Mairi's device could be blazoned as Vert, on a
lozenge throughout ployé argent a golpe charged with a triquetra argent.
Versus Amber's device, there would only a single CD for changes to the
charges on the lozenge. However, the June 2004 Cover Letter has a
section "From Wreath: Alternate Blazons and Conflicts which states in
part:
This month we registered ...on a pale argent fimbriated vert, a peacock
feather proper despite a possible conflict with ...on a pale vert three
fangs palewise Or. The argument was made that both pieces of armory
could be considered as ...a pale vert charged with <stuff>. However, in
order for the new submission to fit this interpretation, it would be
blazoned as ...on a pale vert a pale argent charged with a peacock
feather proper. That would be four layers, which is unregisterable.
Since the unregisterable blazon is the only blazon under which the
conflict exists, this is not a conflict.
In this case, Vert, on a lozenge throughout ployé argent a golpe charged
with a triquetra argent is an unregisterable blazon and is the only
blazon under which the conflict exists, thus it is not a conflict.
|
| 21. |
Miriam von Schwarzwald
<Forgotten Sea> |
NAME |
Name Passed as
Miriam vom Schwarzwald
Submitted as Miriam von Schwarzwald, this byname almost
always appears with the definite article (von dem Schwarzwald). This
preposition/article combination is usually contracted to vom. We have
changed the name to Miriam vom Schwarzwald to correct the grammar. |
| 22. |
Mirabel Wynne
<Cúm an
Iolair> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Or, a sun azure
eclipsed argent and a bordure azure estoilly argent. |
| 23. |
Mór
inghean Chathail
<Cúm an
Iolair> |
BLANKET PERMISSION TO
CONFLICT & HERALDIC WILL |
Blanket permission to
conflict is granted for any armory that is one CD away from her
registered device, Or, in pale two tygers passant contourny queue-forchy
purpure. Heraldic Will
Recorded |
| 24. |
Tristram ap Cynydd
<Crystal Mynes> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
as
Tristram Cynydd
Submitted as Tristram ap Cynydd, the byname Cynydd is an
occupational term meaning "huntsman." In this situation, the byname
should either be used without the patronymic marker (Tristram Cynydd
meaning "Tristram the huntsman") or with the definite article y (Tristram
ap y Cynydd meaning "Tristram son of the huntsman"). Given the
documentation on the form, we believe that the submitter is interested
in the former. Therefore, we have dropped the patronymic marker and
registered this name as Tristram_Cynydd.
Device Returned:
This conflicts with Freydís in tryggva Sigurðardóttir,
Or, a chevron between three birds close sable. There is a single CD
for changing the type of secondary charges. |
| 25. |
Viola de Verde
<Aston Tor> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per fess purpure and
vert, in chief a pair of angles fesswise interlaced in pale Or and a
base wavy barry wavy argent and vert. |
| 26. |
Wolfgang van Zanten
<Deodar> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Returned:
This conflicts with Melchior Erasmi von Frankfurt,
Argent, a bend sinister between two crosses crosslet fitchy sable. There
is a single CD for changing one of the crosses to a decrescent. The
fitching of the cross is worth no difference. |
| |
|
|
|
The following items have been sent out
an External Letter of Intent (ELoI) to Laurel.
We are awaiting
notification of results.
ELoI Letter
Designation:
20050610-LOI-CAL-MDB
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
June 10, 2005
Date the Laurel-of-Arms Office decides on these submissions:
October 2005
Date the Saker Herald Office received the results of the Laurel decisions: |
| |
Submitter's Name & Group |
Item(s) |
Decision by Laurel |
| 1. |
Alana inghean Tigernán
<Calanais Nuadh> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Alana filia Tigernáin
Originally submitted as Alana filia
Tigernán, the name was changed at kingdom to Alana
inghean Tighearnáin because the patronymic phrase mixed
Latin and Irish in violation of RfS 3.I.a, Linguistic Consistency.
However, for languages where the practice of mixing Latin with
vernacular spellings in a patronymic is well documented, such
combinations may be allowed. This is the case for Old and Middle Irish;
an examination of the various Irish Annals and other Irish manuscripts
found at the CELT site (www.ucc.ie/celt) reveals numerous examples where
both the given name and patronymic are in Gaelic, while the patronymic
marker used is the Latin filia or filius. The Annals of
Ulster entries for 730 have Bran filius Eugain and Oitecde
m. Baithectde, filius Blathmicc, in 580 Colggu filius Domnaill
filii Muirchertaigh mc. Muireadhaigh, and in 801 Be Fáil filia
Cathail. The Annals of Tigernach show Sebdand filia Cuirc
in 732 and Martha filia Maic Dubain in 758. While using the Latin
patronymic marker is not the usual thing in these manuscripts, it
happens often enough to form a distinctive pattern in Old and Middle
Irish manuscripts. However, we do not find this pattern in Early Modern
Irish documents. Therefore, because of a well established pattern
showing the pattern of Latin patronymic markers used with Gaelic
patronymics in Old or Middle Irish, either a Latin or a Gaelic
patronymic marker may be used in patronymics where the name is Old or
Middle Irish. For patronymics where the name is Early Modern Irish,
only the Gaelic patronymics markers may be used. Because the originally
submitted form of the patronymic, Tigernán, is Middle Irish, it
is acceptable to use the Latin patronymic marker with it. However, the
originally submitted form had the patronymic in the nominative case
rather than the required genitive case. We have changed the name back
to the originally submitted form, put the patronymic in the required
genitive case, and registered the name as Alana filia Tigernáin
Device Passed: Per pale sable and
gules, a phoenix and on a chief Or an ivy vine vert. |
| 2. |
Cassandra Peverell
<Coeur d'Ennui> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Vert, a horse
couchant and on a chief nebuly Or three plumes bendwise sinister sable.
Please instruct the submitter to draw the
chief narrower. |
| 3. |
Cécile Cerise of Mazzardbeare-on-Stitch
<Vatavia> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Cécille Cerise of Cherybeare
Submitted as Cécile Cerise
of Mazzardbeare-on-Stitch, there are several
issues with this name. The given name Cécile is a modern
spelling. However, the spelling Cécille appears in
Aryhanwy ferch Catmael, "Names from a 1587 Tax Roll from Provin." We
have made this change.
More serious, though, is the construction
of the locative byname. First, the overall construction of treegrove-on-piece
of land is not a pattern found in English placenames. The only
examples we have of similar constructions show the pattern
placename+on or upon+river name. However, the element Stitch
is documented only as a generic topographic term meaning "a piece of
land". This is neither an actual placename nor a river name, and its
inclusion in a compound English placename of this sort does not fit the
pattern found for these names. Second, the initial element,
Mazzardbeare is not well formed. We have found no examples of
mazzard or the related maser meaning a "cherry tree" in
English placenames, nor do we have examples of mazzard meaning
"cherry tree" until the late 16th/early 17th C. As such, it is not
appropriate for use in an English placename. However, Mills, A
Dictionary of English Place-Names has several examples of the Middle
English chiri "cherry" used in placenames: s.n. Burton
Cheriburton in 1444, s.n. Hinton Cheryhynton in 1576, and s.n.
Willingham Chyry Wylynham in 1386. Ekwall, A Dictionary of
English Place-Names s.n. Rockbeare has the deuterotheme -bear(e)
in Rockbear in 1275. Cherybeare , meaning "cherry grove"
is a possible form for such a placename. We have changed the name to
Cécille Cerise of Cherybeare in order to register it.
Device Returned:
Conflict
This is returned for
conflict with the badge of Da'ud ibn Auda, (Fieldless) An apple gules
slipped and leaved proper. There is one CD for fieldlessness, but
no more.
The cherry does
appear to be a period heraldic charge: Parker, p.104, cites the example
of Cheriton, Bishop of Bangor 1436-37: ... on a chevron between
three martlets ... as many cherries stalked; in chief three annulets...
(The ellipses are because we don't know tinctures; presumably this is a
stone carving or other tinctureless rendition.) The only reason we know
they're cherries is from the cant.
On the other hand,
Fox-Davies (Complete Guide to Heraldry, p.209) says that "Papworth
mentions in the arms of Messarney an instance of cherries. Elsewhere,
however, the charges on the shield of this family are termed apples."
This is confirmed by looking in Papworth, p.428, at the arms of
Messarney: Or, a chevron per pale gules and vert between three
(apples) cherries of the second slipped as the third. The two
different blazons, apples vs. cherries, are found in different editions
of Glover's Ordinary. It would appear that even period heralds had
difficulty telling the two charges apart. As the charges were not
distinct in period, we grant no difference between an apple and a
cherry, and this conflicts with Da'ud's badge as cited above. |
| 4. |
Cére Wyther
<Three Rivers> |
NAME CHANGE (from Katharine
Wyther) |
Name Change Passed as
Ceara Wyther
Submitted as Cére
Wyther, as submitted this name is two steps from period practice.
First, it mixes Gaelic and English. Second, there is a more than 300
year gap between the 681 date for the given name and the mid 13th C date
for the surname. Although the surname Wyther is grandfathered to
her, grandfathered names may only violate rules already violated in the
originally registered name. Her original name had neither the language
nor the temporal problems of the submitted name. We have changed this
name to Ceara Wyther in order to register it. Ó
Corrain and Maguire, Irish Names s.n. Cera, lists Ceara as
the latter form of the name of a virgin saint. As saints names are
generally registerable as parts of mixed language names, this removes
the temporal problem.
Device Passed: Per fess Or and vert,
two oak leaves and a full drop spindle inverted bendwise sinister
counterchanged.
Old Name, Katharine Wyther, is
released.
Previous device: Per fess Or and
vert, three oak leaves counterchanged is retained as a badge. |
| 5. |
Dessa Demidova Zabolotskaia
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
As documented, this
name mixes English and German; this is one step from period practice.
However, Rede Boke has found the spellings Elen and Helena
in German. While a name using one of these spellings would be the best
recreation, given these variants, Elena would not be completely
unexpected in German.
Device Returned:
Conflict with Xenia Dimitrievna Morózova, Per chevron throughout
purpure and Or, three compass-stars counterchanged. |
| 6. |
Elena vom Schwarzwald
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Gules ermined
argent, on a bend sinister argent three holly sprigs palewise vert
fructed gules. |
| 7. |
Grímr Skallagrímson
<Flinthyll> |
DEVICE |
Device Passed: Sable, a boar
passant and on a chief Or three Thor's hammers gules. |
| 8. |
Günther Klaus von Stuttgart
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Or, a stag's attires
and a bordure sable. |
| 9. |
Hamr grar Ulfr
<Flinthyll> |
NAME |
Name Returned:
Multiple problems.
This name has
several problems. First, it is unlikely that Hamr is actually a
given name. The only undisputed example we have of this name is from
Hrólfs saga kraka ok kappa hans, where it is one of a pair of names
assumed by two young brothers in hiding so they won't be killed; the
adopted names are Hrani and Hamr. Now, Hrani is
found as a given name, but it is also a word meaning "a blusterer". The
word hamr means skin or cover, and is particularly connected to
legends of skin-changers or shape-shifters. As such it is a perfect
descriptive nickname or disguise name for a young boy in hiding to
adopt. However, this makes it much less likely to be a reasonable given
name. All other citations found were for placename etymologies where
equally likely alternative etymologies were also given (either the place
is derived from a different name, or the word "hamr" in the name is
descriptive). Unless Hamr can be found in a non-allegorical
sense used for a regular human being, it cannot be registered.
The bynames were
intended to mean "gray wolf". For a properly formed byname, there should
not be a space between the two elements. Argent Snail notes: "Lind's
book on bynames has several bynames starting with grá- like grábarði
(greybeard) and grátoppr (greytop, greyhair). Thus a byname meaning 'greywolf'
would probably be written 'gráúlfr', as one word, not two." However, no
examples of Old Norse bynames of the form color+animal have been
found; by precedent they are not registerable:
[Kristin
Hvithestr]. Lacking solid evidence of a clear pattern of descriptive
bynames of the form [color] + [animal] in Old Norse, there is no support
for the submitted Hvithestr as a plausible descriptive byname in Old
Norse. (West, Dec 2003)
Because the
submitter cares most about the meaning "Hamr Gray Wolf", and because we
cannot construct a name with the submitter's desired meaning, we are
returning this. However, if the submitter is interested in a name with a
similar sound, we suggest Hamundr grai Úlfsson or Hamall grai
Úlfsson. These names means "Hamundr/Hamall the gray, son of Úlfr".
Both Hamundr and Hamall are found in Haraldson, The Old
Norse Name, and are names from the Landnamabok, so either of
these would be a reasonable Old Norse name.
|
|
10. |
Ichikawa
Moromoto
<> |
DEVICE
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Sable, on a hawk's
bell argent a quatrefoil sable. |
|
11. |
Ichikawa
Moromoto
<> |
BADGE
RESUBMISSION |
Badge Passed: Argent, on a hawk's
bell sable a quatrefoil argent. |
| 12. |
Istvan of Deodar
<Deodar> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per pale sable and
argent, a double-headed phoenix and in chief a pair of hands appaumy,
within a bordure counterchanged. |
| 13. |
Juliana de Léon
<Vatavia> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Returned:
Aural conflict
Aural conflict with
Julienne de Léon, the bynames are identical, and the only
difference in the pronunciation of the given names is the a possible
J to Y first sounds and the vowel in the unstressed final
syllable.
Device Returned:
Returned for redraw.
The device is
returned for redraw. The thimble is not recognizable as such; the most
common guess for this charge was a tombstone. Charges must be
identifiable from their appearance, per RfS VIII.3. |
|
14. |
Kathalyn
Nimet
<> |
Letter of
permission to conflict |
Recorded
The permission to conflict is for
anything that is one countable step different, or a CD, from her
registered badge, Or, a dolphin vert finned and beaked and in base
two bars wavy purpure. |
|
15. |
Kathalyn
Nimet
<> |
Letter of
release |
Recorded release of name: Ceara
inghean Ghallchobhair uí Chionaoith. |
| 16. |
Mevanwy verch Tuder Courtecadeno
<Three Rivers> |
BADGE RESUBMISSION
|
Badge Passed: [Fieldless] On a
beehive purpure, a bee Or. |
| 17. |
Mikhail Zabolotskii
<Three Rivers> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Quarterly Or and
sable, two bear's pawprints sable. |
| 18. |
Órækja Óttarson of Tonsberg
<Vatavia> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Órækja Ottarsson j Tunsbergi
Submitted as Órækja Óttarson
of Tonsberg, the submitter requested
authenticity for 12th-14th C Norwegian language/culture. The given name
and patronymic were documented as Old Norse, however the 12th-14th C
Norwegian forms are very similar. Lind, Norsk-Isländska Dopnamn Och
Fingerade Namn frän Medeltiden vol 6 s.n. Órókia, lists the spelling
Órækja in both 1236 and 1356; it is a fine given name for this
period. "Diplomatarium Norvegicum", http://www.dokpro.uio.no/dipl_norv/diplom_felt.html,
lists the patronymic Ottarsson in 1346 and 1347. The locative is
found in the same collection as Tunsberg in 1294, and in its
genitive forms Tunbergi and Tunberghi at various points in
the 14th C. We have changed this name to Órækja Ottarsson
j Tunsbergi, a fully 14th C form of this name,
to fulfill the submitter's request for authenticity.
Device Passed: Quarterly Or and
vert, a cross gules between two feathers bendwise sinister argent. |
| 19. |
Philippé du Rouchard
<Vatavia> |
DEVICE RESUBMISSION
|
Device Passed: Per pale argent and
azure all estencely, a fleur-de-lys counterchanged |
| 20. |
Rhiannon Ross
<Vatavia> |
NAME |
Name Passed
Rhiannon
is SCA compatible. |
| 21. |
Rohese de Dinan
<Shadowdale> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Ermine, on a bend
sinister azure three horse's heads palewise coupled Or. |
| 22. |
Ros Fionn inghean Domhnall
<Three Rivers> |
DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Rós Fhionn inghean Domhnaill
Device Passed: Azure, a wilf
couchant contourney and on a chief triangular argent a rose proper.
Please
advise the submitter to draw the chief wider in the center. |
|
23. |
Svein
sutari svithanda
<> |
DEVICE
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Argent, a bottell
sable between three ogresses.
The leather bottell is a period
heraldic charge. It was used as a charge by the Worshipful Company of
Horners since at least the end of the 16th C. (Armorial Bearings of
the Guilds of London, Bromley & Child, pp.141-142.) Baron Bruce
Draconarius has provided an illustration of the Horners' leather bottell,
which can be found at the end of this LoAR. The submitted emblazon
depicts an actual period bottell; not a perfect duplicate of the charge
used by the Horners, being less stylized and with smaller loops, but
clearly the same charge. |
| 24. |
Thóra Jódísdótter
<Flinthyll> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed as
Thóra Jódísadóttir
Device Passed: Or, an elfbolt and
on a chief azure three decrescnts Or.
Submitted as Thóra Jódísdótter,
the grammar of the byname is incorrect. The correct form of a feminine
patronymic of the name Jódis is Jódisardóttir.
We have made this change.
Please
instruct the submitter how to draw proper decrescents. |
| 25. |
Vladimir Krasnoboroda
<La Grande Tente> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per fess gules and
Or crusilly Russian Orthodox counterchanged. |
The following items have been sent out
an External Letter of Intent (ELoI) to Laurel.
We are awaiting
notification of results.
ELoI Letter
Designation:
20050820-LOI-CAL-MDB
Date the ELoI Letter left the Kingdom:
August 20, 2005
Date the Laurel-of-Arms Office decides on these submissions:
December 2005
Date the Saker Herald Office received the results of the Laurel decisions: |
| |
Submitter's Name & Group |
Item(s) |
Decision by Laurel |
|
1. |
Alexander
Sage
<Cum an
Iolair> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Argent, a pall
inverted bretessed sale between three wyverns gules. |
|
2. |
Anastasia
de Carrera
<Heraldshill> |
NAME |
Name Passed as
Anastasia da Carrara
Device Passed: |
|
3. |
Anna der
Schatz
<Heraldshill> |
NAME |
Name Passed as
Anna Die Schatzin
|
|
4. |
Brian Mac
Tomás Uí Fhoghladha
<Forgotten
Sea> |
NAME |
Name Passed as
Brian mac Tomáis Uí Fhoghladha
|
|
5. |
Constance
Wilkicke
<Forgotten
Sea> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per pale gules
and sable, on a bend argent three footprints palewise sable. |
|
6. |
Cum an Iolair,
Canton of
|
DESIGNATOR CHANGE to Shire |
Change recorded |
|
7. |
Cum an Iolair,
Shire of
Sub: Talon
Herald |
HERALD TITLE |
Name Passed
|
|
8. |
Einarr
Grímsson
<Flinthyll> |
NAME |
Name Passed
|
|
9. |
Friedrich
von Bayern
<Ridgehaven> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Bendy sable and
argent, a double-headed eagle azure and a bordure embattled gules. |
|
10. |
Giudo di
Niccolo Brunilleschi
Sub: Mishka
Lamanov
<Deodar> |
NAME -
Alternate & BADGE |
Name Passed
Badge Returned:
Returned for redraw - willow slip not
identifiable as such. |
|
11. |
Heraldshill, Shire of |
BADGE |
Badge Passed: Gules, in fess
two straight trumpets Or. |
|
12. |
Isabel la
Fouchiere
<Lost Mor> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Per fess fleury
counter-fleury gules and sable, three towers, one and two, argent. |
|
13. |
Johan
Berger
<Heraldshill> |
NAME & DEVICE |
Name Passed
Device Passed: Azure, an eagle
on a chief argent three fleurs-de-lys azure. - Nice Armory |
|
14. |
Juliana
Macnayre
<Heraldshill> |
DEVICE -
RESUBMISSION |
Device Passed: Per pale azure
and purpure, a triskelion arrondy pommenty and a chief Or. |
|
15. |
Luci | |